⚖️ Free tool

Roth vs Traditional 401(k) Calculator

Compare two simplified retirement-tax models using your own assumptions. Choose whether to compare the same plan contribution or roughly the same current take-home cost, then change tax rates, years and expected return to see how the modeled outcomes move.

Educational model only. This calculator does not enforce IRS or employer-plan contribution limits, catch-up rules, eligibility, matching formulas, deductions, credits, payroll taxes, required distributions, early-withdrawal rules or changing tax brackets. It assumes qualified Roth withdrawals for the modeled Roth result. It is not financial, investment or tax advice.

How to read the comparison

With same plan contribution, both sides receive the same annual contribution and compound at the same assumed return. The Traditional ending value is then reduced by the future withdrawal tax rate you entered. This makes the tax-rate assumption especially visible instead of hiding it inside the calculator.

With same estimated take-home cost, the Roth contribution equals the amount you enter. The calculator estimates a larger Traditional contribution using your current marginal income-tax rate, because a pre-tax contribution may reduce current taxable income. This is only a mathematical comparison and can produce a contribution above a real plan or legal limit, so the tool intentionally flags that it does not enforce limits.

What this tool deliberately does not decide

Future income, tax law, retirement withdrawals, employer matching, investment returns and personal circumstances can all change. The result therefore says modeled difference, not “winner.” Try several plausible tax-rate and return assumptions to see how sensitive the comparison is.